Selected Book
A Tribe Apart: A Journey into the Heart of American Adolescence (Ballantine Reader's Circle)
- Paperback
- Author: Patricia Hersch
- Publisher: Ballantine Books
- Release Date: August 1999
- ISBN-10: 034543594X
- ISBN-13: 9780345435941
- List Price: $14.95
Price Comparisons
E-mail these Cheap Book Prices to a friend!
| Store | Price | Condition | Free Shipping? | Online Coupons and Deals | |||
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Amazon | $0.01 as of 1/8 11pm EST | Used | NO, $3.99 |
| |||
| Half.com | $0.75 as of 1/8 11pm EST | Used | NO, $3.49 to $3.99 |
| |||
| Half.com | $2.30 as of 1/8 11pm EST | New | NO, $3.49 to $3.99 |
| |||
| Amazon | $4.67 as of 1/8 11pm EST | New | NO, $3.99 |
| |||
| Amazon | $10.17 as of 1/8 11pm EST | New | YES, spend $25+ |
| |||
| TextbookX | $11.13 as of 1/8 11pm EST | New | YES, spend $49+ |
| |||
| button not working? Click Here | |||||||
Summaries and Customer Reviews provided by Amazon
SummaryWhy do teenagers so often seem like a different species? Journalist Patricia Hersch gives a troubling answer in her fascinating, up-close-and-personal look at what it means to be a teen in today's American high schools. Rather than interviewing "high-risk" teens (those already swept up in a cycle of drug use, gang violence, or unintended pregnancy, for example), Hersch focuses her attention on "regular kids"--adolescents who are average achievers on academic and social levels. In light of this, A Tribe Apart is all the more startling to read: Hersch's investigative approach makes it impossible for parents to shrug off their responsibilities by saying "That's not my kid." This is your kid. Hersch offers readers a fly-on-the-wall perspective as she spends three years hanging out with eight youths, submerging herself in their environment. They struggle with all the things you might remember or expect from the teen years: figuring out relationships, establishing friendships, determining what's cool and uncool, experiencing sexual attraction. But these teens--and, as Hersch asserts, the majority of teens in America today--have much, much more piled on their plates. Having been left to their own devices by a preoccupied, self-involved, and "hands-off" generation of parents, adolescents have had to figure out their own system of ethics, morals, and values, and rely on each other for advice on such profound topics as abuse, dysfunctional parents, and sex (with all its accompanying ramifications). Adolescents are indeed "a tribe apart," but not by choice--adult society abandons them long before they ever get the chance to rebel against it. A wake-up call for all parents and teenagers, this essential book is also hopeful. Hersch urges us not to be afraid of teenagers--even if they have piercings and tattoos and strange hair--because what they really, truly want is a little guidance, attention, and love. --Brangien Davis |
Customer Reviews
Average Rating:
well written and naive
Patricia Hersch seeks to go inside that crazy tribe of americans known as adolescents. To do so, she informs the reader that she had to earn the trust of the her subjects (mostly high-schoolers from VA.). After slowly earning this precious trust, Hersch was led inside the world of adolescence where she seeks to make some sense of the blooming, buzzing confusion. Only problem is, I remember being an adolescent not so long ago and it was nothing like Hersch's description.
A couple of problems surface quickly: 1) the life of most adolescents is extremely mundane. 2) Hersch believes every tale her subjects tell her, reminding one of the gullible Margaret Mead fooled by her Somoan subjects. 3) There is absolutely no theory of adolescent behavior to connect the many disparate strands of this story, hence they hang together by gossamer.
Even if one is willing to overlook these flaws, one cannot overlook the fact that the book fails to capture the feeling of being in a tribe apart. Hersch is a very able writer, but she is not so deft at painting a realistic portrait. In some ways this book feels very artificial; like Hersch tried too hard.
Sad, then, that this book is often looked upon as a bible for adults struggling to understand school violence and bullying. To do so requires a more penetrating, less naive view.
If you are shocked that teenagers talk about and have sex, do drugs, skip classes, beat each other up, and have trouble with anomie and alienation, read this long tome from front to back, please! However, if you realize this as a matter of course and are looking for explanations rather than descriptions, I suggest you turn elsewhere. Too bad. Hersch attempted a magnum opus but ended up producing a Salieresque piece of mediocrity.
Totally Irrelevant
Even assuming this is a good book with accurate information, it might as well be stored in a vault. I graduated in 1994, and I have a middle school child myself. The kids in the book are my generation, and I don't really need to read a book about that - lived it! Teenagers today are as dramatically different as we were to our Baby Boomer parents. They are tech savvy, and also the girls have been dressing "sexy" since they were toddlers, showing their stuff in front of the local "Libby Lu's". The In short, this book is a waste of time.
Recommend this, even though it is dated
The existing reviews cover many of the crucial points, though I would like to reiterate how parents and teachers could benefit from the insights these teens provide.
It's often too tempting for adults to measure the success of our youth with illusionary criteria, avoiding what's at the heart of things. I found the teen's accounts of their lives and Patricia Hersch's conclusions realistic and hopeful.
Though there are some tough scenarios, overall the reader is left with a spirit of assurance that youth is an amazingly resilient time of life and a few cultural corrections can make the difference between dire consequences and an aspired future.
A Tribe Apart
A very interesting and captivating book. The best alternative to a text for a graduate level Adolecent Behavior course.
compelling
Partrica Hersch is on a mission. In her book A Tribe Apart, an in-depth study of the lives, behaviors, and opinions of eight adolescents, Hersch argues that today's teenagers are victims of an uncaring, un-involved adult community. Hersch's teens, for the most part, raise themselves. They grapple with adult-sized problems such as abortion, drug use, crime, physical abuse, and neglect--all while facing the "normal" slings and arrows of adolescence. Teens solve the problems they face with very little adult interaction, with the educators, parents, and other adult mentors conspicuously absent. Hersch concludes that today's teens don't exist in a moral vacuum, as social critics might suggest. Instead, she presents teens who reason, debate, and make choices--all without adult guidance or support. The adults who populate the teens' worlds are neglectful--ranging from abusive stepparents, over-worked mothers, self-absorbed fathers, or educators more concerned with discipline and control than forming relationships with kids. It is little wonder that the decisions they make are poor ones. While I do agree with other reviewers that Hersch makes wide-sweeping generalizations about teens and their relationships to adults based upon a limited sample, her point that teens are facing increasingly trecherous problems alone is well-taken. It's easy to feel demoralized after reading A Tribe Apart, and one wonders how adolescence will continue to devovle in the coming decade.