Summaries and Customer Reviews are supplied by Amazon.com

Average Customer Rating:

I'ts all absurd

Customer Rating:

It's all abusrd. We fear death, we're arrogant enough to think that we will survive our own death. All basic religious doctrine is flawed, absurd, ignorant. And this books shows that. Even if GOD existed, how can someone (a priest, a rabine, anyone) affirm that God's talking through him? Even if God existe, how can someone can calim that he is basiccaly good and benevolent? How can he permit the atrocities mankind make? If God is pereftc, how he created a morality-flawed all-powerful animal like the human being? And why did he not make it at once, instead of waiting millions and millions of years of evolution? and why... Weel, I'm gonna stop here. Religion (mainly organized religion) is almost a crime in my opinion. We're all gonna die and the Universe will not miss us at all (and we will not miss it too, because that's oblivion). The differences between us and a fly or a whale is that we can wreck havoc on Earth and, also, we are able to leave behind souvenirs of our existence to those who are atill alive, by means of books, photos, movies, letters, art, constructions, etc, etc, etc.

The best of the One True Theisms

Customer Rating:

I only got twenty pages into this epic and realized that I didn't have to read it at all. A waste of my money. You don't need "science" to prove God doesn't exist--it's painfully clear that only uneducated bumpkins would believe in such a fairytale rubbish. Thank God I'm not an uneducated bumpkin but instead a tenured college professor! The Pope has nothing on me when it comes to infallibility. The book then is clearly meant for superstitious types, possibly even illiterates (One hopes it is available as a book-on-tape!). Why would any intelligent grown-up who is (of course) already an atheist bother to examine and consider any proof of what they already know to be true? That's the sort of circular thinking one finds among the silly Bible-beaters. Anyway, even with only twenty pages under my belt, it was apparent that the author had the issue 99.99% cinched. The concluding cap on this particular jar of raspberry preserves would be the very nearly almost completed (and yet strangely allusive) Theory of Everything, AKA (near 50 or 60 years ago) the Unified Field Theory (there was another name for it 100 years ago but I've forgotten what it was). Thankfully, that ultimate final answer to all questions about the universe is (as always) just around the next corner. Have you heard about Quantum Chromo-Superdooperstring Theory yet? All we have to do is find something called a Thisbe Boson and it is GAME OVER!

Forget about God, Victor Stenger doesn't exist ....

Customer Rating:

...well at least in a few more years he won't. I'm an agnostic and nothing riles me more than a rabid theist, except maybe a rabid atheist. Nobody knows - or will ever know - how and why we are here. Stenger proves nothing. In fact he offers this take on Leibnitz' questions, "Why is there something, rather than nothing"? Stenger's answer is that "Nothing is unstable". Since physical science is basically inductive and relies on observation and experiment, this is NOTHING more than a guess since it can never be verified. How is this any better than, "God did it". Stenger also quotes physicist Steven Weinberg, " With or without religion people can behave well and bad people can do evil; but for good people to do evil - that takes religion." How about my quote, "With or without physics people can not blow things up or bad people can blow things up; but if you really want to blow up all of Hiroshima - that takes a physicst." Now here is my cyclic Big Bang theory. First, there is this very old, giant, green monkey with a gastrointestinal problem. Then there is this eruption of a hot,gas cloud. Then the galaxies form ... after awhile critters form ... then another giant green monkey is born and the whole thing starts over again. I'm sure this is right, except the part about the color of the monkeys.

Relief

Customer Rating:

Believers will not be swayed by this book of rational arguments, of course, because they are not interested in separating history from mythology when it comes to their beliefs. Their faith is blind faith and most will defend it to the death, usually someone else'. So this book is not for them. But the few rest of us will find great comfort in this book. You are not crazy to disbelieve in the unprovable despite the enormous pressure to do so. You are rational, sane and the only real hope for the future.

Best of its kind

Customer Rating:

Although it is rather presumptuous of me to say this, I believe that Stenger's book is THE BEST OF THE LOT of recent books poo-pooing God. I read the Stenger book in its entirety, and just loved it, even though I am something of a "lapsed atheist" or whatever. I found his discussions thorough, entertaining, and illuminating. I have read extensive excerpts from and reviews of the other books, and none of them tempted me. This one did. I'm glad I succumbed to the temptation. It's a great read.