Compare prices and save on cheap books at CheapestBookPrice.com
Compare prices and save on cheap books at CheapestBookPrice.com HACKER SAFE certified sites prevent over 99.9% of hacker crime.
Go to CheapestBookPrice USA!Go to CheapestBookPrice UK!
Multi-Store Book Search
  
(What's this?)
Selected Product:

The Panda's Thumb: More Reflections in Natural History
The Panda's Thumb: More Reflections in Natural History

Paperback
Author: Stephen Jay Gould
Publisher: W. W. Norton & Company
Release Date: 1992-08
ISBN-10: 0393308197
ISBN-13: 9780393308198
List Price: $16.95
Average Customer Rating:
Score = 4.0 Score = 4.0 Score = 4.0 Score = 4.0 Score = 4.0
Similar Products

Hen's Teeth and Horse's Toes
Hen's Teeth and Horse's Toes
ISBN-10: 0393311031
ISBN-13: 9780393311037
List Price:$16.95


The Mismeasure of Man
The Mismeasure of Man
ISBN-10: 0393314251
ISBN-13: 9780393314250
List Price:$17.95


Bully for Brontosaurus: Reflections in Natural History
Bully for Brontosaurus: Reflections in Natural History
ISBN-10: 039330857X
ISBN-13: 9780393308570
List Price:$17.95


Ever Since Darwin: Reflections on Natural History
Ever Since Darwin: Reflections on Natural History
ISBN-10: 0393308189
ISBN-13: 9780393308181
List Price:$15.95


The Flamingo's Smile: Reflections in Natural History
The Flamingo's Smile: Reflections in Natural History
ISBN-10: 0393303756
ISBN-13: 9780393303759
List Price:$16.95


Our Review: To use our price comparison to get the cheapest price, please click on the "Find the Cheapest Price" button located above for The Panda's Thumb: More Reflections in Natural History by Stephen Jay Gould (ISBN-10: 0393308197, ISBN-13: 9780393308198).

At this time we have not yet written a review for The Panda's Thumb: More Reflections in Natural History by Stephen Jay Gould (ISBN-10: 0393308197, ISBN-13: 9780393308198). Please continue to keep checking back to this page as we are constantly adding reviews.

Summaries and Customer Reviews are supplied by Amazon.com

Summary:
With sales of well over one million copies in North America alone, the commercial success of Gould's books now matches their critical acclaim. Reissued in a larger format, with a handsome new cover, The Panda's Thumb will introduce a new generation of readers to this unique writer, who has taken the art of the scientific essay to new heights. Illustrations.

Customer Reviews
Average Customer Rating: Score = 4.0 Score = 4.0 Score = 4.0 Score = 4.0 Score = 4.0

In Memorium
Customer Rating:  Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5
This is the book that reminds us why Stephen Jay Gould was the Great One. He was perhaps the greatest naturalist of his generation, as measured by being able to get across complex scientific ideas for the common man in an interesting manner. Additionally, he was a great scientist in his own right. The world is a sorrier place to lose him.

Gould's essays are far-ranging, but center around his view of life and evolution- through punctuated equilibrium. Using analogy (allowed in natural history essays) and his extensive research experience, he looks at how paradaigms shift, and why they should. He describes the evidence and logic behind a punctuated model as opposed to gradualism. And along the way lets us learn some fascinating new worlds in human and animal life.

At times I don't agree with his strong dislike of religion. At times his writing is dated- to be expected in a book now 25 years old. (He talks with great excitement about how we can now determine the code of RNA.) But his writing is always interesting, always thought-provoking and challenging, always novel. He has a new way of seeing things, even after a quarter century. He forces the reader to confront their preconceptions and shift their paradaigms. You learn, yes, but with great joy, and a spice of humor.

Muddled thinking ... If it's worth doing, it's worth doing badly.
Customer Rating:  Score = 1 Score = 1 Score = 1 Score = 1 Score = 1
Just a quick note on the theme argument of these essays. Its reasoning is void. Mr. Gould's argument seems to be 1. God is the author only of the perfect; 2. nature, e.g. the Panda (in regard at least to its thumb) is imperfect; 3. therefore, God did not create. The problem with this argument is that the meaning of "perfect" is never analyzed seriously. For example, is the Panda imperfect ? Gould offers nothing in support of this but the failure of the Panda to live up to his, Gould's, rather coarse, idea of "perfect". The text here seems remarkably neglectful of ecology, especially coming from a biologist. More fundamentally, as God is perfect, immaterial being, why should He make *anything* less perfect than Himself, for instance a material world of any kind ? By Mr. Gould's argument, the mere existence of the world, it matters not whether "perfect" or "imperfect", shows that God does not exist. Let's all sit down and go through this again ...

Two Panda's Thumbs up!!
Customer Rating:  Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5
The "argument from design" traces back at least to the medieval theology as a favorite proof for the existence of God. The argument runs that the exquisite design and interrelation of earthly organisms can be explained only by the existence of an Intelligent Designer.

I continue to believe in God, but Stephen Jay Gould's essays in "The Panda's Thumb" is a rather large nail in the coffin of this argument.

In essay after essay, Gould describes nature's mistakes and improvisations, seeming proof against the work of an intelligent designer. For instance, the "thumb" of pandas -- a specialized appendage to strip leaves from bamboo shoots -- is not a true thumb, but a weirdly-designed extension of a wrist bone. Gould demonstrates many other animal adaptations, from orchids to hermit crabs, that use unlikely body parts to perform survival tasks required by later generations of organisms.

Gould's explanation of neoteny - the tendency of organisms to retain anatomical features from childhood - is one of his most fascinating chapters. With a simple mutation, the basis for much uniquely human behavior and anatomy comes in to focus. We humans don't develop elongated snouts like other mammals; we retain our capacity to play throughout our lives rather than abandoning it at puberty; our brains continue to grow after birth; we are helpless and dependent on our parents far longer than other mammals. And in a typically Gouldian play of ideas, he charts the changing facial features of Mickey Mouse over the years to show him being drawn with more infant -like (and therefore human-like) features - rounder head, bigger eyes, shorter snout.

Though Gould is not a theist, "Panda's Thumb" is not an argument against God, but *for* the appropriate use of science to describe the natural world. We theists are well-served by books like this, which give us the ammunition needed to battle cultural forces that seek to blind us to the truth that lies right in front of us in the natural world and of which we are a part.

Evolutionary theory meets Mickey Mouse and selfish genes
Customer Rating:  Score = 4 Score = 4 Score = 4 Score = 4 Score = 4
The second collection of Gould's articles from Natural History continues to explore Darwin's themes and the resultant ideas since. There's several interesting essays here, including my favorite one in which the evolution of Mickey Mouse is discussed.

One of the essays here dealt with Richard Dawkins' controversial stand (in The Selfish Gene) on genes in which he states that a person is just a gene's way to make another gene. (This is different from normal evolutionary thought in that genes there are the subject of random variation which then is subject to the environment and tested.) Gould is not convinced by Dawkins' theory, mainly because, he says, there is no evidence that genes can be linked to specific attributes, i.e., there isn't an "eye" gene. Gould wrote this some years back, so it will be interesting to see if he revisits this subject now that researchers have indeed discovered the "eye" gene (through testing on flies).

Gould also covers Robert Bakker's theories about warm-blooded dinosaurs (later written up in Bakker's The Dinosaur Heresies) and the link to birds, a good essay for people to review prior to the hullabaloo that will follow Jurassic Park 2 (it's always fun to check up on an author's source material).


Enjoyable but dated
Customer Rating:  Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5 Score = 5
An entertaining and elegantly written collection of discursive essays on natural history and evolution. The nature stories and the anecdotes about eccentric naturalists are interesting.
It has a 1980 original publication date. Perhaps because of this date there is very little about DNA and nothing about HLA and tissue-typing. I shall check his later books to see if he ever got up-to-date on these. (He died a month ago). He was concerned to defend his field as being real science against "haughty and high-riding mathematicians and experimentalists." In fact this sort of biology seems more akin to history and archeology than to hard science, but that adds to its readability rather than detracts from it.

























Suggestions | Book Store Reviews | Site Map | Book Reviews | Contact Us
© 2008 . All rights reserved. Privacy Statement and Disclaimer
web site design and support by Crystal Solutions